Career Power

What If I'm Skeptical About Executive Coaching?

Ricardo Cruz, Founder of QARETE · November 7, 2026 · 13 min read

What If I'm Skeptical About Executive Coaching? — QARETE Insights

TL;DR

  • Skepticism about coaching is not a flaw to get over. It is a filter, and a good one. A lot of coaching sells vibes instead of results.
  • The real question is not "does coaching work?" It is "does this coach teach me why, or just hand me their steps to copy?" Copied steps get a short-term result. Understanding the why builds something that lasts.
  • Top performers use coaches to see what they cannot see in themselves. Surgeon Atul Gawande hired one at the peak of his career (Gawande, 2011).
  • End any coaching call where the coach promises a promotion, guarantees an outcome, or claims to be the only one who can help you.
  • Good career coaching does not hand you a promotion. It helps you build a case you can defend and earn the sponsors who will argue for it when you are not in the room.
  • Coaching is not for everyone. If you cannot take honest feedback, save your money.

Your skepticism is earned

If you have been passed over for a promotion, or you are eyeing a leadership role and not sure you are ready, coaching probably sounds like one more thing to pay for that might not work.

That instinct is right more often than the coaching industry would like to admit. Coaching is unregulated. Anyone can use the title. And plenty of it runs on language that sounds good and delivers nothing you can measure: "unlock your potential," "get your mindset right," a page of affirmations.

Affirmations feel nice. But words don't get you promoted.

So don't drop the skepticism. Use it. The goal is not to talk yourself into coaching. It is to know exactly what to test for, so you can tell a coach who will move your career from one who will just take your money.

I know this from the client side, because for years I was the skeptic who hired the wrong coaches.

I was the client who kept hiring the wrong coach

For a long time I chased being "fit." I hired coach after coach, and I picked them on two things: they looked like the future version of me I wanted to be, and they had a decent following on social media.

That was it. Those were my criteria.

The results were hit and miss. Could I get a result fast by following a very prescriptive plan? Yes. Did I enjoy the result? Sort of. Did I learn the habits to keep it? Absolutely not.

I went through the motions. Tracked everything, did the workouts, got the result, and then slid right back. Every time it happened, I came away believing a little more that the long-term result I wanted, actually feeling good in my body, just wasn't available to me.

It wasn't me. It was the method. I had been fitting myself into each coach's picture of "healthy and fit" and following their routine. Nobody ever taught me why I was doing any of it.

What changed: a coach who taught me why

Things changed when I got clearer on my own needs. Not on what a coach should look like, but on what I actually needed from one.

Every coach I had hired before had the muscle to prove their own hard work. What I hadn't realized was that I love the science of weightlifting. So I needed a coach with real education in the functional mechanics, someone who could teach me why each movement works, not just show me what to do. Why this exercise and not that one. What a choice would do to the outcome I said I wanted.

That coach also made it easy to ask the "dumb" questions. Instead of trying to teach myself from a box of answers preloaded from someone else's toolkit, I got a real answer to my actual question, plus resources to keep learning on my own.

That is what changed everything. I went from confused, trying to reconcile a dozen influencers' conflicting strategies, to methods that actually worked for me. Once I understood the why, I didn't need someone standing over me. I could adjust as things changed and make my own calls.

The day I am writing this, I lifted 120% of my previous personal record on squats. That didn't come from following a routine harder. It came from knowing what the routine was for.

Careers work the same way. A coach who hands you their playbook can get you through one promotion conversation. But careers move: managers leave, budgets get cut, criteria shift. If all you learned was a script, you are back to square one the next time anything changes. A coach who teaches you why your evidence lands, and why a decision-maker says yes or no, gives you something you keep.

That is the first test for any coach. Do they put you in their box, or do they help you build your own roadmap to the outcome you need?

The best performers aren't struggling. They're coached.

One of the most common doubts is that coaching is for people who are failing. The evidence says the opposite.

In 2011, surgeon and writer Atul Gawande described hitting a plateau after eight years in the operating room. He wasn't struggling. He was very good and had stopped getting better. So he asked a retired surgeon who had trained him to watch him operate. That coach came out with a page of specific notes, down to where Gawande held his elbows and where he stood so the light fell on the operating field (Gawande, 2011). These were small mechanics that Gawande could not see from inside his own performance.

No amount of hard work fixes a blind spot. You need someone outside your own head to see it.

The pattern holds at the top of business, too. A Stanford and Miles Group survey of more than 200 CEOs, directors, and senior executives found that nearly two-thirds of CEOs were getting no outside coaching, yet nearly all of them said they would welcome it and were open to changing based on feedback (Stanford Graduate School of Business, 2013). The researchers described a shift away from seeing coaching as remedial and toward seeing it the way elite athletes do: a way to improve performance. That survey is from 2013, so treat the numbers as dated. The point still holds.

Pro teams have head coaches and assistant coaches. Elite athletes have coaches who tailor their goals and push their limits. None of them are struggling. They know the next level takes insight they can't generate alone.

Three doubts, answered honestly

"I can figure this out myself."

Maybe you can. You are capable, and that is not in question. But the thing about a blind spot is that you can't see it. Things are easier with a partner, and an honest coach will name the gaps you have been working around and give you a plan that accounts for them. That is the whole lesson of Gawande's elbows.

"Coaching is for people who are struggling."

It's not a rescue service. It's a performance tool. The people at the top of nearly every field use one, and the executives who don't mostly say they wish they did (Stanford Graduate School of Business, 2013).

"I can't justify the cost after being passed over."

Fair. So ask the harder question: can you justify the cost of staying the same?

Another year in the same seat costs you the raise, the scope, and the momentum you would have had in the next role. Then it costs you again the year after. If you want to put numbers on it, our guide on how to choose an LGBTQ+ career coach walks through a simple personal ROI formula you can run on your own situation.

The research is encouraging, too. A meta-analysis of coaching in organizations found meaningful positive effects on performance, skills, well-being, and progress toward goals (Theeboom et al., 2014). But it also shows that coaching isn't magic. Results depend on the work and on the fit.

Red flags that should end the call

Most of vetting a coach is about fit. A few things, though, should end the conversation immediately.

  • They promise you a promotion. Promotions are decided by other people: your manager, a calibration committee, a budget. No coach controls that, and one who says otherwise is selling you something they can't deliver.
  • They guarantee an outcome. Same problem. Career decisions are subjective. A coach can't guarantee what a room full of other people will decide.
  • They tell you they are the only one who can help you. A good coach builds your independence. One who builds your dependence is working against the thing you hired them for.

For the full vetting process, including the questions to ask on a discovery call, what credentials mean, and what coaching should cost, read How to Choose an LGBTQ+ Career Coach (and What It Should Cost).

What good coaching actually builds: your case and your sponsors

Here is the honest answer to what coaching delivers. It doesn't deliver a promotion. It delivers readiness you can prove.

Being a hard worker isn't enough anymore. Hard work gets you a good review. Being ready to show evidence of your readiness, and having people who will make that case for you, is what gets you the next role. You need two things:

  1. A case. Clear evidence of the scope you already handle, the decisions you have led, and the results that changed because of you, put together so a decision-maker can act on it.
  2. Sponsors. People with influence who will put your name forward in rooms you are not in yet.

Beth Ford, the first openly gay woman to become a Fortune 500 CEO, has described her career in exactly these terms. Her view is blunt: "Nobody, I promise you, cares more about your career than you do" (Doyle, 2021). She didn't wait to be noticed. She told leaders directly which role she wanted and asked what she would need to do to be considered. When leaders told her they didn't see her in a bigger role yet, she treated it as useful information and asked what would change their view. She also met regularly with her CEO and made her ambition to lead the company plain (Doyle, 2021).

That isn't luck, and it isn't confidence as a personality trait. It's a system: state the target, collect the evidence, ask for honest feedback, close the gap. That is the work The QVANT Method™ is built around. You quiet the doubt by replacing perception with evidence, define the role you want precisely, audit the skills, relationships, and track record you already have, choose your path, and take the first move.

Your story, your strengths, and how much you share at work stay yours to decide. A good coach never asks you to become someone else, and never pushes you to be more out than you choose to be. The goal is the fully realized version of you, owning your career.

Who should not hire a coach

I'll be direct, because you deserve the same honesty I'd give a client.

Coaching will not work if you are not open to feedback.

Growth takes looking honestly at where you actually stand and what it will take to get where you want to go. If you want someone to hand you a checklist so you never have to question your own approach, coaching will disappoint you. I can give you a playbook. But careers change, and the playbook only works if you can take the feedback and adjust.

The same goes for ego. If you already believe you're better than most of the people around you, you won't be able to look at yourself honestly, and without honesty you can't see where you're going clearly.

Research on coaching backs this up. The strength of the working relationship between coach and client, which depends on trust, candor, and agreement on goals, is one of the most consistent predictors of results (Graßmann et al., 2020). Coaching only works if you'll actually hear what you're told.

If you're not there yet, that's fine. Start for free: ask three people you trust what they see as your biggest strength and your biggest blind spot, and just listen. If you can hear their answers without arguing, you're ready.

Your next move

Keep your skepticism. Point it at the right questions.

Don't ask whether coaching works. Ask whether this coach will teach you why, help you build a case you can defend, and leave you stronger without them.

If that's the kind of coaching you're looking for, see how QARETE's LGBTQ+ career coaching works, or start at qarete.coach.

You were not built to blend in. You were built to execute.

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Is executive coaching worth it if I've just been passed over for a promotion?

It can be, if the coaching focuses on what decides promotions: clear evidence of your readiness, clear criteria, and the right sponsors. It isn't worth it if the coach is selling mindset work with no way to measure progress.

How do I know if a coach is legitimate?

Coaching is unregulated, so look for a defined process, clear success criteria agreed up front, a written agreement, and honesty about what coaching can't do. Our coach selection guide has a full checklist.

Can a career coach guarantee a promotion?

No. Promotions are decided by other people. A coach can help you build your case and prepare you for the conversations that matter. Treat any guarantee as a red flag.

What's the difference between a coach who teaches the why and one who just gives steps?

A steps-only coach gives you their routine to copy. A coach who teaches the why explains why each move works, so you can adapt when your manager, company, or goals change.

Do I have to be out at work to work with QARETE?

No. What you share, and when, is always your choice. QARETE is outcome-focused career coaching. It never requires or pushes anyone to come out.

What if I'm not sure I'm coachable?

Try the free test above: ask three people you trust for your biggest strength and your biggest blind spot. If you can hear the answers without defending yourself, you're ready for coaching.

References

Doyle, K. (2021, July 7). Beth Ford on being the champion of your own career. Stanford Graduate School of Business. https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/beth-ford-being-champion-your-own-career

Gawande, A. (2011, October 3). Personal best. The New Yorker. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2011/10/03/personal-best

Graßmann, C., Schölmerich, F., & Schermuly, C. C. (2020). The relationship between working alliance and client outcomes in coaching: A meta-analysis. Human Relations, 73(1), 35–58. https://doi.org/10.1177/0018726718819725

Stanford Graduate School of Business. (2013, July 31). David Larcker: "Lonely at the top" resonates for most CEOs. https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/david-larcker-lonely-top-resonates-most-ceos

Theeboom, T., Beersma, B., & van Vianen, A. E. M. (2014). Does coaching work? A meta-analysis on the effects of coaching on individual level outcomes in an organizational context. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 9(1), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/17439760.2013.837499

For private support turning this into your next move, explore LGBTQ+ career coaching.

Next step

Find out which stage you should start at.

Take the free diagnostic →

Related

More in Career Power